home about us late availability family holidays adventure holidays responsible tourism community destination guides contact us

The New York Times - Treading Lightly On the Road to Mandalay

May 7 2006, The New York Times, Joshua Kurlantzick

Treading Lightly On the Road to Mandalay


THE blob of traffic in front of our car had stopped dead. Having arrived in Mandalay from crowded Bangkok, I'd hoped to escape gridlock, but here I was, just 30 minutes after touchdown at the airport, in bumper-to-bumper again. Frustrated, I poked my head from the car, and was immediately pelted -- with garlands of jasmine.

I swiveled my head, and found myself staring into a crowd of Burmese girls standing on the bed of a truck festooned with ocher prayer flags. I had blundered into a novice ceremony, a festival celebrating the entrance of young girls into the local Buddhist nunnery. Burmese preteenagers in fuchsia and white robes, with crowns of garlands and gold leaf atop freshly shaven heads, stood on pedestals in the trucks, queens for the day. Truckloads of relatives held parasols over the girls' heads and tossed garlands into the street. Monks chanted while bands of wood drums and thin flutes belted out reedy atonal melodies.

As Southeast Asia modernizes rapidly -- Starbucks appears to be colonizing Thailand -- Myanmar, as Burma is now called, remains the last country in the region preserved in amber. In Myanmar, men still wear saronglike lungis rather than pants, and traditional rituals like the novice ceremony, rather than new-model Mercedes, still hold up traffic. Western influences are almost nowhere to be found. ''We go nowhere,'' one Burmese businessman told me over drinks at a sailing club in the capital, where the wooden dinghies were cracking. ''What can we do? Have another drink.''

There's a reason for this sensation of being stuck in time, of course. Decades of rule by one of the world's harshest military regimes have left the country isolated and its economy a shambles, discouraging tourist arrivals, putting modern amenities out of many people's reach, and keeping the Burmese wedded to traditional life. (In 2005, Myanmar received some 660,000 foreign visitors, according to the government, compared with the more than 11 million in Thailand in 2004, as reported by the Tourism Authority of Thailand.) ''There's only one destination where we won't market holidays, and that's Burma,'' said Justin Francis of Responsible Travel, a British travel agent promoting socially responsible trips. ''We'll market trips anywhere else where we think it'll benefit local people -- even Zimbabwe.''

The country's name alone suggests the perplexing state of affairs, and the political side that some travelers take even before deciding whether to visit. What was once Burma was renamed Myanmar by a 1989 military edict. But some people in the West -- particularly those human rights activists who argue that the current regime is one of the most oppressive in the world and has used forced labor to build some tourist sites -- still call it by its traditional name.

Like Responsible Travel, and Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, the pro-democracy opposition leader, many Myanmar-oriented human rights groups support a boycott of tourism, which they see as endorsing the government. The groups draw up ''dirty'' lists of travel agencies that send tourists there, blast publishers of Myanmar guidebooks, and try to shame celebrities who visit, like Mick Jagger. ''It's naïve to say you can help as a tourist,'' said Tricia Barnett, director of Tourism Concern, a British group advocating responsible tourism, who believes that most of the tourist infrastructure remains closely linked to the regime.

For other travelers, convinced their tourism dollars will help average Burmese, the appeal of the last truly Asian place in Southeast Asia is exactly the reason to come. ''When I was in Burma, I've never met anyone who said that I shouldn't be there,'' said Andrew Gray, founder of Voices for Burma, another advocacy group. Mr. Gray argues that educated tourists can spend money on local businesses without government links and help average people in one of Asia's poorest nations.

The call for a boycott has sparked fierce debate on Web sites and in hotels across the Asian backpacker trail. ''I don't know of any debate that's as vocal as this one,'' said Brice Gosnell, a regional publisher at Lonely Planet. That's not necessarily bad. The debate educates potential visitors, and many independent travelers I've encountered have waded through political tomes before choosing to go, though package-tour tourists normally have not done the same.

I've visited Yangon, as Rangoon is now called, more than five times in the last decade, including most recently in March. Each time, I rise early my first morning for a pilgrimage to the northern end of the city's axis, the Shwedagon Pagoda. ''It is of a wonderful bignesse, and all gilded from the foot to the toppe,'' wrote the first Englishman to visit Myanmar, Ralph Fitch, in 1586, upon glimpsing Shwedagon.

The pagoda still towers over the skyline today, a 326-foot-tall bell-shaped spire over 1,500 years old, gilded in layer after layer of precious metals and set with over 5,000 diamonds and other gems. Below the main spire sit hundreds of smaller stupas, and in the morning, Shwedagon's jewels reflect the sun like a disco ball, tossing multicolored light in every direction.

On this March morning, the marble floors, heated from the sun, scorch the soles of my bare feet. For some Yangon residents, Shwedagon has become such a central part of life that they seem totally at ease there. As I wander into the shade, I notice groups of men lying around the pagoda's elevated base while snacking on chips and even occasionally bathing with buckets of water near the central stupa. Others prostrate themselves in the sun, praying to a statue supposed to grant miracles to childless women.

South of Shwedagon, in the middle of a busy intersection, lies the other end of the axis, the Sule Paya -- another gilded temple that's nearly 2,000 years old. Just outside Sule Paya, surrounded by traffic, I stop at a tea shop. Despite military rule, the Burmese remain avid consumers of news -- I see numerous people holding transistor radios to their ears -- and dispensers of gossip. And tea shops, where you can sit for hours digesting salads and Indian-style snacks and chewing betel nut, a mild narcotic whose red juices stain Yangon's streets, have always been where the best gossip is tossed around.

In the late 1980's, political conversations and fights at tea shops helped ignite an antigovernment revolt, which culminated in the party of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi sweeping the national election in 1990, the first free vote in three decades. But the regime ignored Mrs. Aung San Suu Kyi's victory and she has been under house arrest on and off since, along with at least hundreds of other political prisoners. In the last two years, the junta has become even more reclusive, moving ministry buildings from Yangon to a jungle redoubt in central Myanmar, reportedly on the advice of an astrologer, and building a personality cult around the senior general, whose photo adorns nearly every newspaper in the Sule Paya tea shop. According to the Free Burma Rangers, a relief and advocacy organization based in Thailand, more than 11,000 Burmese have fled their homes in recent months.

Meandering south, I lose myself in the warren of crumbling colonial buildings, some with posters advertising screenings of ''Missing in Action,'' a 20-year-old Chuck Norris flick, or magazines 15 years out of date. Once scrubbed outposts of the British Raj, the buildings have begun to succumb to the humidity, but structures like the old High Court, an imposing Victorian red brick edifice crowned with a Big Ben-style clock tower, retain an imperial majesty. On the waterfront, I wander into the lobby of the Strand, the classic Yangon hotel where steamer ships once disgorged maharajahs, princes and other nobility of the Raj. Elegantly restored, down to the white-suited liverymen opening the hotel doors, from inside the Strand's tearoom one could still think the sun hasn't set on Britannia.

No pukka sahibs are in sight anymore outside the Strand, though -- Yangon, a city of some four million people, has become one of the most diverse cities in the region, and Myanmar has over 130 ethnic groups. Off narrow 26th Street, I notice a Star of David on a metal gate, and I poke inside. Moses Samuels, a Burmese man in a checked lungi, comes out to meet me. ''Are you Jewish?'' he asks. When I nod, he leads me into the Musmeah Yeshua Synagogue, where he serves as caretaker for one of the most stunning examples of Sephardic Jewish architecture I've seen. From the altar, I can see the powder blue detail work on the ceiling, and while I'm staring, Mr. Samuels pulls back a curtain and reveals two torah scrolls from Iraq.

Fifty years ago, Yangon had a thriving Jewish community made up mostly of immigrants from Iraq, but today, Mr. Samuels says, it has dwindled to eight families, and his own son now studies in New York. Still, he remains proud of his community, and his country. ''We still get 40 or 50 people on Rosh Hashanah,'' he says.

As I push through crowded alleys that smell like chapatis, I see ethnic Indians with henna-tinged beards and red dots on their foreheads eating masala dosa at street stalls and ethnic Chinese merchants weighing bars of gold on aging scales. At a biryani stall, I am surrounded by ethnic Burmans, the majority, smearing on thanaka, a paste that supposedly provides sun protection but resembles war paint, giving Yangon the look of a city constantly prepared for a medieval battle.

From the 11th to the 13th centuries, devout Burmese monarchs built at least 4,000 temples in Bagan, across more than 20 square miles in central Myanmar's wide plains. Roughly 400 miles north of Yangon stands this monument to Burmese civilization, one of the most impressive architectural achievements in Asia. Though some original temples no longer exist, there are still thousands on the plains, from slim cathedral-like buildings to stocky, square monuments. Some reach 180 feet high, with elaborate terraces, porticos and bas-reliefs.

In contrast to other monuments like Angkor Wat in Cambodia, Bagan still receives so few tourists that you can hike among ruins for hours without seeing another person. At dusk, I can sit at one of the temples, undisturbed as I watch perhaps the most spectacular sunset in Asia, the sun bathing the temples in purple and crimson, creating silhouettes of the ancient stupas, and finally setting over lush fields.

By the time the British took over the country in the late 1800's, the center of Burmese royal attention had moved north to Mandalay, along the chocolaty Ayeyarwady River. As capital of Myanmar, Mandalay too became a center for Buddhist scholarship.

Today Mandalay, close to neighboring China, has also become a vibrant economic and cultural center. In the older part of town, I walk into homes where women still weave kalaga, the hand-embroidered tapestries traditionally used to decorate royal palaces. In the newer section of town, a friend and I wander through a glass-and-steel shopping mall dominated by Chinese electronics and fashions, where Burmese salesgirls peddle short dresses. When my friend asks one salesgirl whether it's acceptable in Myanmar's conservative culture for her to wear thigh-high boots and spike heels, she replies that it's not a problem -- even as elderly women in long frocks and traditional turbans stare into the store, seemingly mesmerized.

As everywhere in Myanmar, tourists in Mandalay cannot avoid encountering the government. Outside the colonial-era Mandalay Fort, an austere walled city around a shimmering moat reportedly rebuilt with forced labor, signs vow that the army will ''crush'' all enemies, and troops stop cars at will. Gangs of workers dig ditches along the airport road, and several travelers I spoke with saw what they believed to be forced labor in this region.

Local tour guides can be frank in their critiques; mine pointed out checkpoints where the police and soldiers constantly asked for bribes, before adding, ''I can only talk like this alone, in the car'' and asking me never to reveal his name. In Mandalay's theater area, home to Myanmar's companies that put on pwes -- a kind of vaudeville where actors perform into the early morning -- this dissent often plays out through art. Traditionally, pwes centered on broad jokes and interpretations of classical theater, though they also could be used to send subtle political messages, as performers could joke about topics commoners would never tell the king. Under military rule some performers once again use pwes and music for a kind of back talk to authority; in Yangon, Burmese gangsta rap has become a vehicle for mild dissent.

MY last evening in Mandalay, I visit a decrepit dirt street to see Myanmar's most famous vaudevillians, who have paid a steep price for their laughs. In an open front room that doubles as a makeshift stage, the Moustache Brothers perform every evening.

Two of the three Brothers were arrested a decade ago for telling jokes critical of the government, and served nearly six years in prison. (Western comedians pressed for their release, and Hugh Grant mentioned them in the movie ''About a Boy.'') Today, the regime allows them to perform only for tourists, and for $3 a person they stage a bizarre mix of snippets from gorgeous classical Burmese dance, topical political humor, playful banter and attempts to frighten the audience. Indeed, the six people in the crowd around me seem alarmed when Lu Maw, a wiry Brother who mixes stories of government corruption with odes to Jennifer Lopez's booty, jokes that he's running out the back door because the police are coming.

Some of their comedy feels more like tragedy -- at one point, Lu Maw asks me to steal toiletries for him from my hotel -- but the Brothers never waver in poking fun at their rulers. As the evening draws to a close, they invite the audience to pose for photos with them, holding signs warning that the guests will now be under surveillance in Myanmar. ''Show this to the police and see what happens,'' Lu Maw dares me, handing over his business card.

For the time being, and under this government, average Burmese like Lu Maw can only rely on the traditions that have sustained them so long.

On a previous trip to Myanmar, I drove outside the capital to Bago, a small town famous for its reclining Buddhas. I had time, so I drove to a local monastery. When I pulled up, the gate was closed, and as I began walking back to my car, I heard someone call, ''Come here, come in'' -- an elderly monk with a red robe.

He opened the gate, and I followed him into the monastery, through a maze of antechambers. Just when I concluded we were lost, the monk stopped, pushed open a side door and prodded me in.

Inside, I saw a hall the size of a basketball gym, with hundreds of young boys in novice monk robes sitting cross-legged in front of worn books -- reams and reams of Buddhist scriptures. As a senior monk led them, the boys were painstakingly learning to read, memorizing the ancient scripts as well as modern Burmese and trying to chant in time, though I noticed several dozing on the ground. Focused on their task -- probably their only chance at an education in Myanmar today -- none even noticed a foreigner. The monk smiled, ushered me out, and closed the door behind us.

STRATEGIES FOR DECIDING AND FOR SPENDING JUDICIOUSLY

HOW TO GET THERE

Before planning a trip, you might want to read up on the country and its political situation so you can make an informed decision on whether to go. The Lonely Planet is the best English-language travel guide to Myanmar, and the Irrawaddy magazine (www.irrawaddy.org), published in Thailand, covers Burmese news online, including in-depth reports on the current political situation. If you are in Thailand and decide not to go into Myanmar, advocacy groups like the U.S. Campaign for Burma (www.uscampaignforburma.org) can help arrange trips to the Thai-Myanmar border, where you can meet Burmese refugees.

The United States State Department simply warns Americans traveling to Myanmar to avoid crowded public places, and demonstrations. In my five visits to Myanmar, I have never feared for my safety.

No international carriers fly direct to Myanmar from the United States, so your best bet is to fly to Bangkok or Singapore and continue on from there. From Bangkok, Thai Airways (www.thaiairways.com) flies to Yangon; in late April, a mid-May round trip was $266. From Singapore, Silk Air (www.silkair.com), the regional wing of Singapore Airlines, flies to Yangon; in late April, a mid-May round trip was $440. Get paper tickets for your flight to and from Myanmar, as the country's airport system is antiquated; e-tickets will prove useless.

Once in Myanmar, stick to Air Mandalay (www.airmandalay.com) if you can for your domestic flights. The State Department has advised embassy employees to avoid the state-owned Myanmar Airways ''due to serious safety concerns,'' including two fatal crashes in 1998.

You can book tickets over the Internet on Air Mandalay, through travel agents in Thailand or Singapore, and then pick up your tickets before you get to Myanmar; I used Myanmar Travels in Singapore (mtt@pacific.net.sg; 65-6535-3870). Be aware that there are frequent delays and postponements on domestic flights, so allot plenty of time.

If you want to give as little money as possible to the Myanmar government, you can adopt several strategies. Avoid taking package tours, and make local transport and accommodations arrangements with an independent Burmese travel agent, who will most likely know how to avoid many government-owned shops and other attractions. Travelers' recommendations of local travel agents can be found on Lonely Planet's Thorn Tree Web site, www.thorntree.lonelyplanet.com. I found an excellent agent and guide there. Inside the country, if you have conversations with Burmese about politics and government, let them guide the discussion and don't ask politically charged questions.

If you don't use a local travel agent to arrange your flights, accommodations and other details, you can book flights and some upscale hotels online and then arrange local transport yourself once you arrive in Myanmar. Discounts at many Burmese hotels can be found at www.asiarooms.com. In most towns and cities, it's usually easy to find a car and driver for the day, either through your hotel or by bargaining with local taxi drivers, most of whom speak some English.

You must obtain a visa before arriving in Myanmar; information is available at www.mewashingtondc.com.

WHERE TO STAY

Most hotels in Myanmar set their rates in U.S. dollars, the de facto currency, along with the local currency, the kyat. Take plenty of dollars, as most places do not accept credit cards or traveler's checks, and make sure your dollar bills are crisp, as the Burmese do not accept wrinkled or torn dollars.

In Yangon, I stayed at the Dusit Inya Lake (37 Kaba Aye Pagoda Road; 95-1-662857; inyalake.dusit.com), an upper-end hotel outside the center of town, run by a Thai company, with a relaxing terrace overlooking Inya Lake. The rooms have satellite television, and there is a pool and a health club; using AsiaRooms.com I paid $40 for a single, with breakfast. I also have stayed at the Haven Inn (216 Bo Myat Tun Road; 95-1-295500), a simple but comfortable guesthouse in the eastern part of the city, where air-conditioned single rooms go for $10. If you prefer a more colonial experience, try the Pansea Yangon (35 Taw Win Road; 95-1-299860; www.pansea.com), a restored teak mansion once used to house chieftains from the country's many ethnic groups. At AsiaRooms.com, Pansea rooms start at $130.

In Mandalay, I stayed at the Sedona Hotel (junction of 26th and 66th Streets; 95-2-36488; www.sedonahotels.com), probably the finest choice in town, with views over Mandalay Fort. I paid $65 a night for a single, again through AsiaRooms.com. I have also stayed at the Royal Guest House (41 25th Street, between 82nd and 83rd Streets; 95-2-31400), with friendly staff members and clean, air-conditioned (vital in Mandalay's heat) rooms starting at $7.

In Bagan, try to stay in Old Bagan, close to the more impressive temples, rather than in the more modern town of Nyaung U. In Old Bagan, the Bagan Hotel (Near Gawdawpalin Temple; 95-62- 60032 or baganhotel@myanmars.net) sits right by the Ayeyarwady River. Rooms start around $60.

WHERE TO EAT

Yangon offers the country's most diverse dining scene. The foreigner-oriented Sandy's Myanmar Cuisine (95-1-382918), next to the Kandawgyi Palace Hotel, with a long patio offering unrivaled views of Kandawgyi Lake and its copy of a royal barge illuminated like a Christmas tree, offers a lengthy menu that can serve as an introduction to Burmese cuisine. Dinner for one, including fish steamed so tender that the bones dissolved, cost me roughly $10.

The Yathar Tea Centers and Cafe (353 Mahbandoola Road, two stores down from a large photography shop) offers tea shop cuisine like Indian rotis and curries, and Aung Thuka (between Shwe Gon Daing and Dhama Zedi Roads, near the Shwedagon Pagoda) serves more homey Burmese cooking; at either place meals for one cost less than $5.

The Mandalay restaurant at the Pansea hotel (35 Taw Win St; 95-1-229-860) serves classy Burmese-French fusion food, like giant local prawns with beet root dressing, in a stately neo-colonial atmosphere. Dinner for one cost me $35.

In Mandalay, Green Elephant (27th Street between 64th and 65th Streets; 95-2-61237), in a thick outdoor garden, offers Westernized Burmese curries and dishes from the Shan area of northeast Myanmar. Dinner for one cost me $10.

For a change from Burmese, Marie Min restaurant (27th Street between 74th and 75th Streets) serves basic Indian vegetarian dishes and many flavors of lassis and fruit juices. Lunch for one costs about $5.

READING

Myanmar's lush scenery and internecine, troubled politics have inspired numerous travelogues and works of fiction. Among the best are ''The Trouser People: A Story of Burma in the Shadow of Empire,'' by Andrew Marshall, and ''The Piano Tuner,'' a novel by Daniel Mason.

JOSHUA KURLANTZICK is a special correspondent for The New Republic.

Copyright 2007 The New York Times Company
Convert currencies